But man, I am frustrated. There are so many questions I can’t get an answer to, and indeed the answers may not exist. If they do, and you know them, or if I say something that betrays my short interest in this subject, speak up!
OK, so I really like period instrumentation. I could care less about the instruments actually being original to the time. I think I’ve talked about this regarding the Wrecking Crew of LA studios. Those guys didn’t use vintage instruments—they were new at the time—so I don’t especially care about vintage equipment, as long as new equipment is being made to the original specs now. For me, I think a large part of my interest in period ensembles comes from an almost visual aesthetic. And now we come to my issue: Period ensembles that I’ve seen just don’t seem “exotic” enough. I feel like even the best and most authentic ensembles take things for granted that they shouldn’t. For instance, new scholarship is postulating that when Bach (JS, of course) wrote for “Violoncello,” he was not refering to what we think of as a “baroque cello” but instead an instrument played “da spalla.”
Like this:
That just feels right to me. And I’m uncomfortable with assumptions that when Bach or Handel called for violas that they always meant the “modern” viola. I feel like I’d like to see more baroque ensembles use treble viols. And when Handel calls for “bassi”, he probably did often mean cello, but how interesting would a performance of the Messiah be with no celli, but Violas Da Gamba? And a very interesting question that seems to be getting asked in these circles is that of the role of a contrabass string instrument.
How often did baroque composers really want a so-called 16’ instrument? In the Brandenburgs, Bach occaisionally calls for “Violone Grosso,” but does that mean he wants the bassline doubled at 16’ by a bass viol? Or at the written pitch? Likewise, when Handel writes “bassi” does that include a “double bass”?
Maybe there are people out there who know such things, but they aren’t publishing the answers.
There are some ensembles that seem to be closer to the exoticism I seek. These are mostly the opera ensembles of Montiverdi, Handel, et al. in these, you see theorbos and archlutes and Viols—and it feels distant, and foreign.
On another note, I think that there’s some really cool packaging done for Classical music CDs that really make a difference. Working in the music section of my store, as I often do, I come across a lot of unattractive album covers. I’m not going to give examples. But the right packaging and art goes a long way to making some of this very old music seem cutting edge.
The Gardiner Bach Cantata Pilgimage series is a good example, nice digipack-type packaging, with awesome cover art:
I also really enjoy these Vivaldi Opera covers as seen here:
http://www.amazon.com/Vivaldi-Farnace-Zanasi/dp/B001V76E10/ref=pd_bxgy_m_img_c
Check out the other ones in that series.


